Modular vs Civil Kitchens: A Comparison

Are you a new homeowner or someone who is thinking about refurbishing their kitchen? If so, you certainly have a few choices to make. Should you take the traditional route and get a carpenter to build you a kitchen or get a designer-approved fully-functional modular kitchen? It’s not an easy choice, given that carpenters have always been the preferred choice, but factory-made modular designs seem to have a better finish! Here’s out take on the modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchens debate. This article hopes to answer all your queries in a simple and practical way.

Modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchens_definitions
Pros and Cons of a Modular Kitchen

A modular or a machine-made kitchen seems like the hottest thing in the market, but comes with its own set of pros and cons. Keep reading.

Modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchen_bright kitchen
Pros:
  • The sleek construction and layout of the modular kitchen gives your home a neat look
  • It is easy to assemble and reassemble the modules of a modular kitchen and you can easily carry them with you if you shift homes
  • Engineered wood that is used in modular furniture is preferred in the long run for its durability as opposed to solid wood that can be hard to maintain
  • Quality is assured by all the modular kitchen manufacturing units since they are factory-made products
  • Storage is never a problem with modular kitchens, since you can get customised storage with a designated space for everything
  • There is no stress of carpenters working and creating a mess at home, since everything is made in the factory and only assembled at the site
  • Cost stays true to estimate, provided there are no substantial changes to design
Modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchen_subtle kitchen
Cons:
  • Let’s face it, building a modular kitchen might leave a hole in your pocket, because quality always comes at a price
  • The use of engineered wood has received some flak from some critics
  • Maintaining glossy or matte finished cabinets will require some level of effort
  • Sometimes you might like something on paper but not in reality. Ensure your designer gives you an accurate picture of the actual design
Pros and Cons of a Carpenter-Made Kitchen

Having understood what a carpenter made kitchen is, it is also essential to understand the pros and cons of it. Let’s take a look..

Modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchen_kitchen under construction
Pros:
  • Being an age-old method of building a kitchen, this is a more relatable technique. Carpenters are locally available and more easy to approach
  • It is easier to play around with the budget because these carpenters are comparatively more flexible with pricing
  • You can ask for customisation options or alterations since carpenters will do all the work in front of you
Modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchen_building material
Cons:
  • Quality and finish is a concern when it comes to carpenter made kitchens, since it is all hand work
  • The carpenter also fixes the kitchen cabinets permanently. So you cannot dismantle the cabinets. Thus, if you’re moving, you’ll have to leave everything behind
  • Costs keep fluctuating with carpenters
  • It can be hard to get them to design something that is currently in vogue
  • Visualisation can be a task with carpenters as opposed to designers who can give you a sense of what your kitchen will look like with 3D designs
  • With carpenter-made kitchens, you will not have the luxury of getting machine-techniques like edge banding
Modular Kitchen vs Carpenter-made Kitchens: The Verdict

Having read this, one can safely conclude that modular kitchens are way better that carpenter made kitchens in terms of quality, finishes and variety. But, carpenter-made kitchens are the clear choice if you can deal with fluctuating costs and the task of dealing with carpenters. Make a wise choice after consulting with a designer and carpenter to get a clearer idea.

Meanwhile, keep those suggestions and comments coming in. If you’re looking to accessorise your kitchen, refer this article!

editor@livspace.com


Categories : Design, Kitchen
Tags : , ,