Are you a new homeowner or someone who is thinking about refurbishing their kitchen? If so, you certainly have a few choices to make. Should you take the traditional route and get a carpenter to build you a kitchen or get a designer-approved fully-functional modular kitchen? It’s not an easy choice, given that carpenters have always been the go-to people, but factory-made modular designs seem to have a better finish! Here’s our take on the modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchens debate. We hope this gives you all the insights you need.

Modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchens_definitions

Pros and Cons of a Modular Kitchen

A modular or a machine-made kitchen seems like the hottest thing in the market, but comes with its own set of pros and cons. You can pick what you want for your kitchen and optimise it to make the most of a compact space. But is there more you need to know?

Modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchen_bright kitchen
Sleek modular kitchen

Pros:

  • The sleek construction and layout of the modular kitchen gives your home a neat look
  • It is easy to assemble and reassemble the modules of a modular kitchen and you can easily carry them with you if you shift homes
  • Engineered wood that is used in modular furniture is preferred in the long run for its durability as opposed to solid wood that can be hard to maintain
  • Quality is assured by all the modular kitchen manufacturing units since they are factory-made products
  • Storage is never a problem with modular kitchens, since you can get customised storage with a designated space for everything
  • There is no stress of carpenters working and creating a mess at home, since everything is made in the factory and only assembled at the site
  • Cost stays true to estimate, provided there are no substantial changes to design
Modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchen_subtle kitchen
Customised storage options

Cons:

  • Let’s face it, building a modular kitchen might leave a hole in your pocket, because quality always comes at a price
  • The use of engineered wood has received some flak from some critics
  • Maintaining glossy or matte finished cabinets will require some level of effort
  • Sometimes you might like something on paper but not in reality. Ensure your designer gives you an accurate picture of the actual design

Pros and Cons of a Carpenter-Made Kitchen

Having understood what a carpenter-made kitchen is, it is also essential to understand the pros and cons of it. While you know that all your work is done by human hands, increasing the chances of errors, do you know it all?

Modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchen_kitchen under construction
Traditionally, carpenters have been approached to make kitchens

Pros:

  • Being an age-old method of building a kitchen, this is a more relatable technique. Carpenters are locally available and more easy to approach
  • It is easier to play around with the budget because these carpenters are comparatively more flexible with pricing
  • You can ask for custom options or alterations since carpenters will do all the work in front of you
Modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchen_building material
Tools used in building kitchens

Cons:

  • Quality and finish is a concern when it comes to carpenter made kitchens, since it is all done by hand
  • The carpenter also fixes the kitchen cabinets permanently. So you cannot dismantle the cabinets. Thus, if you’re moving, you’ll have to leave everything behind
  • Costs keep fluctuating with carpenters
  • It can be hard to get them to design something that is currently in vogue
  • Visualisation can be a task with carpenters as opposed to designers who can give you a sense of what your kitchen will look like with 3D designs
  • With carpenter-made kitchens, you will not have the luxury of getting machine-techniques like edge banding

Modular Kitchen vs Carpenter-made Kitchens: The Verdict

Having read this, one can safely conclude that in a comparision of modular kitchen vs carpenter-made kitchens, the former is way better that the latter in terms of quality, finishes and variety. But, carpenter-made kitchens are the clear choice if you can deal with fluctuating costs and the task of dealing with carpenters. Make a wise choice after consulting with a designer and carpenter to get a clearer picture.

Livspace provides ready-to-cook modular kitchens delivered in a mere 45 days! Check out your options here.

Send in your thoughts and suggestions to editor@livspace.com.